You have been served with disciplinary charges by your city, town, village, county, or state agency — or you expect to be. Or you are the employer, and you need charges that will survive review. For many New York public employees, the rules come from Civil Service Law § 75, which sets the hearing procedure, and § 76, which governs appeals. Here is who is protected, how the process works, and how a decision can be challenged.
Who Section 75 Protects
A covered employee “shall not be removed or otherwise subjected to any disciplinary penalty provided in this section except for incompetency or misconduct shown after a hearing upon stated charges” (Civil Service Law § 75[1]). Coverage includes:
- employees holding a permanent appointment in the competitive class (Civil Service Law § 75[1][a]);
- honorably discharged veterans who served in time of war, as the Civil Service Law defines it, and exempt volunteer firefighters, in permanent positions in the classified service, other than private secretary, cashier, or deputy (Civil Service Law § 75[1][b]);
- non-competitive or labor class employees with at least five years of continuous service in positions not designated confidential or policy-influencing (Civil Service Law § 75[1][c]); and
- two narrower groups: certain New York City home aides and homemakers, and police detectives with three continuous years in that position (Civil Service Law § 75[1][d], [e]).
Probationary employees are not on the list. The Court of Appeals has held that a probationary employee “may be dismissed for almost any reason, or for no reason at all,” and has no right to a hearing absent a showing of bad faith or an improper or impermissible reason (Matter of Swinton v Safir, 93 NY2d 758, 762-763 [1999]).
Tenured public school teachers generally fall under a different statute. The Education Law provides that a person with tenure may be disciplined or removed only “for just cause and in accordance with the procedures specified in” Education Law § 3020-a, or under alternate disciplinary procedures in a qualifying collective bargaining agreement (Education Law § 3020[1]).
The Charges and the Eighteen-Month Deadline
The employee must receive written notice of the proposed discipline and the reasons for it, and a copy of the charges, and must be allowed “at least eight days for answering the same in writing” (Civil Service Law § 75[2]). The wording of the charges matters, because “findings in a disciplinary proceeding must be based on the charges made” (Matter of Kohn v County of Sullivan, 214 AD3d 1058, 1062 [3d Dept 2023]).
No proceeding may be commenced more than 18 months after the alleged misconduct or incompetency (one year for state employees designated managerial or confidential), unless the conduct “complained of and described in the charges would, if proved in a court of appropriate jurisdiction, constitute a crime” (Civil Service Law § 75[4]). The Third Department applies that exception to the charges as written: where the charges omitted the intent and knowledge elements of official misconduct, they were untimely, and a general reference elsewhere in the notice to criminal statutes did not save them (Matter of De Guzman v State of New York Civ. Serv. Commn., 129 AD3d 1189, 1192 [3d Dept 2015]).
Questioning, Representation, and the Hearing
An employee who, at the time of questioning, appears to be a potential subject of discipline has a right to union representation and must be told so in advance, in writing. If the employee asks, a reasonable period must be allowed to obtain a representative; if the hearing officer finds it was not, statements from the questioning, and evidence obtained as a result, are excluded (Civil Service Law § 75[2]).
The hearing is held by the officer or body with the power to remove the employee, or by a deputy or other person designated in writing, who makes a record and sends it, with recommendations, to that officer or body for decision (Civil Service Law § 75[2]). The hearing officer recommends; the employer decides. One exception: certain paid firefighters in cities of less than one million, towns, villages, and fire districts who are represented by a union are entitled to an independent hearing officer who renders the final decision (Civil Service Law § 75[2-a][a]). The employee may be represented by counsel or a union representative and may summon witnesses. “The burden of proving incompetency or misconduct shall be upon the person alleging the same,” and technical rules of evidence do not apply (Civil Service Law § 75[2]).
Suspension and Penalties
While charges are pending, the employee may be suspended without pay “for a period not exceeding thirty days.” If found guilty, the penalty is limited to a reprimand, a fine of up to $100 deducted from salary, suspension without pay for up to two months, demotion in grade and title, or dismissal, and unpaid suspension time may count toward the penalty. An employee who is acquitted must be restored with full pay for the suspension period, less any unemployment insurance benefits received (Civil Service Law § 75[3]).
When a Union Contract Replaces Section 75
Read the collective bargaining agreement before relying on the statute. Sections 75 and 76 “may be supplemented, modified or replaced” by negotiated agreements (Civil Service Law § 76[4]). Although that sentence refers to agreements with the State, the Third Department, in a decision the Court of Appeals affirmed, held that for local governments too, “disciplinary procedures are not per se prohibited subjects of collective bargaining” (Matter of Auburn Police Local 195 v Helsby, 62 AD2d 12, 17 [3d Dept 1978], affd 46 NY2d 1034 [1979]). A contract may substitute a different procedure, such as arbitration.
Police discipline can be different. “[W]here Civil Service Law §§ 75 and 76 apply, police discipline may be the subject of collective bargaining,” but not where the Legislature has expressly committed police discipline to local officials (Matter of Patrolmen’s Benevolent Assn. of City of N.Y., Inc. v New York State Pub. Empl. Relations Bd., 6 NY3d 563, 570, 573 [2006]).
Appealing a Section 75 Decision
An employee who has been demoted, dismissed, suspended without pay, fined, or officially reprimanded may appeal either to the civil service commission with jurisdiction or to court in an Article 78 proceeding (Civil Service Law § 76[1]). The choice matters.
A commission appeal must be filed in writing within 20 days after service of written notice of the determination (three more days if notice came by registered mail). The commission reviews the hearing record and may affirm, reverse, or modify, including ordering reinstatement with back pay (Civil Service Law § 76[1]-[3]). But its decision is “final and conclusive, and not subject to further review in any court” (Civil Service Law § 76[3]), subject to an “extremely narrow” exception, such as when the commission “acted illegally, unconstitutionally, or in excess of its jurisdiction” (De Guzman, 129 AD3d at 1191 [internal quotation marks omitted]).
An Article 78 proceeding generally must be commenced within four months after the determination becomes final and binding (CPLR 217[1]). If the petition argues that the findings lack substantial evidence, Supreme Court decides any threshold objections and then transfers the case to the Appellate Division (CPLR 7803[4]; 7804[g]). Substantial evidence is “a minimal standard that requires less than [a] preponderance of the evidence” (Kohn, 214 AD3d at 1059 [internal quotation marks omitted]).
A penalty will be set aside only if it is “so disproportionate to the offense, in the light of all the circumstances, as to be shocking to one’s sense of fairness” (Pell v Board of Educ., 34 NY2d 222, 233 [1974]; see CPLR 7803[3]). In Kohn, the Third Department annulled two charges because the testimony showed only a suggestion, not the directive charged, but upheld the termination on the remaining charges given the employee’s role as administrator of a county nursing home during the COVID-19 pandemic (214 AD3d at 1062-1064).
Whistleblower Retaliation as a Defense
Civil Service Law § 75-b bars discipline because an employee disclosed to a governmental body a violation of law that creates a substantial and specific danger to public health or safety, or information the employee reasonably believes is true and is improper governmental action (Civil Service Law § 75-b[2][a]). The employee may raise that as a defense at the Section 75 hearing, and if the discipline was based solely on such a violation, the hearing officer must dismiss or recommend dismissal (Civil Service Law § 75-b[3][a]).
Before the Hearing
For employees: confirm whether you hold a permanent appointment and whether your union contract replaces Section 75, calendar the answer deadline, check the dates of the alleged conduct against the 18-month limit, and weigh the commission and Article 78 routes before any appeal deadline runs.
For employers: describe in each charge the specific conduct you intend to prove; if you rely on the crime exception, make sure the charges themselves describe the elements of the crime; designate the hearing officer in writing; give written notice of the right to representation before questioning; and keep any unpaid suspension within 30 days.
Frequently Asked Questions
Am I covered by Section 75?
Section 75 covers permanent competitive class employees, certain veterans and exempt volunteer firefighters in permanent positions, and non-competitive or labor class employees with five years of continuous service in positions not designated confidential or policy-influencing. Probationary employees generally are not covered, and a union contract may replace Section 75 with a different procedure.
How long do I have to answer Section 75 charges?
The statute requires at least eight days to answer the charges in writing. The notice may set a specific date, and a union contract may set different deadlines, so read both as soon as you receive the charges.
Can I be suspended without pay before the hearing?
Yes, but under Section 75 an unpaid suspension while charges are pending may not exceed 30 days. If you are acquitted, you must be restored with full pay for the suspension period, less any unemployment insurance benefits you received.
How do I appeal a Section 75 decision?
You may appeal to the civil service commission within 20 days after service of written notice of the decision, or bring an Article 78 proceeding in court, generally within four months after the decision becomes final. A commission decision is generally not reviewable in court, so choose the route carefully.
If you have been served with Section 75 charges, or your municipality needs to bring them, our municipal law and employment law practices in Albany can help. You can also contact us directly.
This article is general information about New York law, not legal advice, and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every situation is different; consult a lawyer about your specific circumstances.
